Return to NGC Auction Central Search

Buffalo Five Cents (1913-1938)

Prices and Auction Volume

This page shows trends for Buffalo Five Cents auctions, including prices realized for the top coins sold. With navigation to upcoming and completed Buffalo Five Cents auctions, you'll always know which coins are most liquid in the market. Tables and charts below also show the top-5 coins in this category by volume and historical trends for Buffalo Five Cents.

Buffalo Five Cents (1913-1938) — Top 5 Prices Realized

Rank
Service
Price
Coin
Grade
Date
1 PCGS $264,500.00 1916 DOUBLED DIE OBV 5C MS MS 64 9/21/2005
1 PCGS $264,500.00 1918/7 D 5C MS MS 65 1/6/2010
2 PCGS $258,500.00 1918/7 D 5C MS MS 65 8/10/2013
3 PCGS $253,000.00 1918/7 D 5C MS MS 65 4/28/2009
4 PCGS $195,500.00 1916 DOUBLED DIE OBV 5C MS MS 64 1/7/2009
4 PCGS $195,500.00 1918/7 D 5C MS MS 65 10/17/2012

Buffalo Five Cents (1913-1938) — Top 5 by Volume



Coin Volume
1913 TYPE 1 5C MS 9
1938 D BUFFALO 5C MS 6
1937 D 3 LEGS 5C MS 4
1931 S 5C MS 4
1913 TYPE 2 5C MS 3

Buffalo Five Cents (1913-1938) — MS Volume vs Time



The chart showing Dec-2023 series, Jan-2024 series, Feb-2024 series, Mar-2024 series, Apr-2024 series, May-2024 series, Jun-2024 series, Jul-2024 series, Aug-2024 series, Sep-2024 series, Oct-2024 series, Nov-2024 series.
Click on the chart to enlarge

Buffalo Five Cents (1913-1938) — PF Volume vs Time



The chart showing Dec-2023 series, Jan-2024 series, Feb-2024 series, Mar-2024 series, Apr-2024 series, May-2024 series, Jun-2024 series, Jul-2024 series, Aug-2024 series, Sep-2024 series, Oct-2024 series, Nov-2024 series.
Click on the chart to enlarge

Coins In Category

= Number of Upcoming Auctions
= Number of Auction Prices Realized

Coin
1913 TYPE 1 5C MS 0 3208
1913 D 5C MS 0 1
1913 D TYPE 1 5C MS 0 1094
1913 S 5C MS 0 2
1913 S TYPE 1 5C MS 0 876
1913 TYPE 2 5C MS 0 950
1913 D TYPE 2 5C MS 0 968
1913 S TYPE 2 5C MS 0 1019
1914 5C MS 0 715
1914 D 5C MS 0 847
1914 S 5C MS 0 794
1915 5C MS 0 816
1915 D 5C MS 0 668
1915 S 5C MS 0 562
1916 5C MS 0 1015
1916 DOUBLED DIE OBV 5C MS 0 111
1916 D 5C MS 0 652
1916 S 5C MS 0 565
1917 5C MS 0 584
1917 D 5C MS 0 669
1917 S 5C MS 0 504
1918 5C MS 0 462
1918 D 5C MS 0 554
1918/7 D 5C MS 0 580
1918 S 5C MS 0 381
1919 5C MS 0 794
1919 D 5C MS 0 468
1919 S 5C MS 0 508
1920 5C MS 0 592
1920 D 5C MS 0 408
1920 S 5C MS 0 464
1921 5C MS 0 586
1921 S 5C MS 0 840
1923 5C MS 0 555
1923 S 5C MS 0 751
1924 5C MS 0 443
1924 D 5C MS 0 464
1924 S 5C MS 0 569
1925 5C MS 0 716
1925 D 5C MS 0 462
1925 S 5C MS 0 517
1926 5C MS 0 970
1926 D 5C MS 0 575
1926 S 5C MS 0 975
1927 5C MS 0 738
1927 D 5C MS 0 504
1927 S 5C MS 0 389
1928 5C MS 0 643
1928 D 5C MS 0 779
1928 S 5C MS 0 458
1929 5C MS 0 736
1929 D 5C MS 0 474
1929 S 5C MS 0 841
1930 5C MS 0 978
1930 S 5C MS 0 676
1931 S 5C MS 0 1183
1934 5C MS 0 700
1934 D 5C MS 0 662
1935 5C MS 0 1094
1935 D 5C MS 0 806
1935 S 5C MS 0 951
1936 5C MS 0 1496
1936 D 5C MS 0 1183
1936 S 5C MS 0 959
1937 5C MS 0 2248
1937 D 5C MS 0 1518
1937 D 3 LEGS 5C MS 0 2609
1937 S 5C MS 0 1687
1938 D 5C MS 0 1
1938 D BUFFALO 5C MS 0 5662
1938 D/D BUFFALO 5C MS 0 999
1938 D/S BUFFALO 5C MS 0 1264
Coin
1913 5C PF 0 2
1913 TYPE 1 5C PF 0 247
1913 TYPE 2 5C PF 0 255
1914 5C PF 0 311
1915 5C PF 0 281
1916 5C PF 0 171
1936 SATIN 5C PF 0 496
1936 BRILLIANT 5C PF 0 438
1937 5C PF 0 1121

The prices shown in NGC Auction Central reflect the hammer price plus the auction house's commission.

NGC Auction Central Disclaimer

NGC Auction Central Disclaimer

Disclaimer: The auction prices realized listed in the NGC Auction Central are compiled from a number of independent, third party sources in the numismatic community which NGC believes to be reliable. The auction data listed by NGC may occasionally contain typographical or input errors that can result in incorrect prices realized appearing on the NGC website. Therefore, the prices realized listed in NGC Auction Central are designed to serve merely as one of many measures and facts that coin buyers and sellers can use in determining coin values. These prices are not intended, and should not be relied upon, to replace the due diligence and – when appropriate – expert consultation that coin buyers and sellers should undertake when entering into a coin transaction. As such, NGC disclaims all warranties, express or implied, with respect to the information contained in the NGC Auction Central. By using the NGC Auction Central, the user agrees that neither NGC nor any of its affiliates, shareholders, officers, employees or agents shall have any liability for any loss or damage of any kind, including without limitation any loss arising from reliance on the information contained in the NGC Auction Central.

Help